Welcome and thank you for reading! I have recently been reflecting on what a wonderful shift it is that we are responding to problem behavior differently. Ignoring problem behavior, whether during a work trial or during reinforcement, is no longer a part of PFA-SBT, and I know that many of you have shifted your practice.

I personally have witnessed this shift as it is my privilege to review hours of footage of PFA-SBT implementation from around the world. The shift is to be celebrated. But I have noticed a misunderstanding arises in its place, regarding how the implementer should respond to nondangerous problem behavior (R2s) during instruction (the EO).

The mistaken belief is that in contemporary SBT, one should immediately reinforce all problem behavior, including non-dangerous behavior. I can see where that misunderstanding comes from, because in an analysis (IISCA), we do immediately reinforce any instance of problem behavior. Same in Universal Protocols. But in SBT, this is not the case.

In SBT, we recommend immediately reinforcing any truly dangerous behavior (R1), but not nondangerous behavior. Instead, we recommend the following steps when an R2 occurs during CAB 1- 6:

(1) Empathize
(2) Encourage persistence
(3) Adjust the requirements for reinforcement (privately, not out loud)
(4) Reinforce the next bit of persistence

PFA-SBT is changingYou’ll notice across these steps that the implementer’s response does not include extinction for attention—so we’re still not ignoring problem behavior. The implementer directly acknowledges the behavior and empathizes with the learner. But the implementer’s response does involve other forms of extinction. You might think of this as partial escape extinction, in that the task is not immediately removed and the learner is encouraged to do a bit more, but not as much as they might otherwise been asked to do and perhaps with some help. As the learner persists with their task, they are probably not accessing tangible reinforcers.

Why would we do this? As therapists and teachers, it is our job to help clients and students learn to do hard things. And being able to persist when the going gets tough is a useful skill for everyone. If we were to immediately deliver all reinforcers contingent on a non-dangerous behavior, we would not be helping our students learn to persist.

But we do care about the learner’s feedback, and everyone’s safety, and our rapport, and about not pushing learners to do too much.

I don’t go to the gym, but I hear that if you want to develop your physical fitness, you probably want to work at your edge.

Not too easy, but not so difficult that you can’t move tomorrow and never want to come back. It’s the same idea in SBT.

If the learner lets us know via an R2 that they are nearing their edge, our goal is to empathetically and supportively help them to do just a little bit more-to foster growth and learning but not overwhelm.

After the trial, as always, we ensure that the learner gets back to being happy, relaxed, and engaged (HRE), and we reflect to ourselves: What led to the R2? Is there anything we should change in our teaching next time? If the learner has the necessary communication skills, you could debrief with them when the session is over and ask: “What was hard about that? Do you wish I did anything differently?” And take their feedback into consideration for your next session.

Dr. Ruppel's Reflections on PFA-SBT 2026

I’ve sometimes heard people say that PFASBT/Today’s ABA doesn’t use extinction or doesn’t use escape extinction. In fact, this isn’t true; it’s more nuanced. We do not recommend certain manners of implementing extinction; for example, we generally don’t recommend handover-hand or intrusive physical escape extinction. And we do not recommend extinction under certain circumstances. But in general, SBT does involve some extinction—“partial extinction,” if you will.

Even partial escape extinction. For nondangerous problem behavior and delivered in an empathetic and supportive manner.

If you are interested in learning more or getting support in implementing these practices, consider becoming credentialed in PFA-SBT. In addition to the training you receive while earning your credential, credential holders are invited to free, live webinars in which our team presents recent updates, big ideas, and new discoveries. PFA-SBT Trainers (Level 6 credential holders) are also invited to free meetings with other Trainers and FTF team members to learn about the latest developments, ask questions, and share their work.

Tell Us How We Can Help

To help us design an organizational training, provide on-site implementation support for your staff, and schedule follow-up video conferencing, tell us about you, your organization, and your goals.

Book Meeting
Call Now!